Demystifying the Code Review Process for Non-Technical Folks

Demystifying the Code Review Process for Non-Technical Folks


In today’s digital age, software development stands as a pivotal force behind technological innovation, fueling everything from the apps on our smartphones to the intricate systems operating within global enterprises. An integral component of this development journey is the practice known as code review. To those outside the realm of software engineering, the concept of code review might appear obscure, yet it plays a crucial role in crafting the reliable and efficient technology that underpins our daily lives. Code review is not just about refining code to make it error-free; it’s a proactive measure that significantly reduces the likelihood of outages, ensuring that software not only functions smoothly but also remains resilient against unexpected failures. This peer-based examination process enhances software security, boosts efficiency, and, importantly, mitigates the risk of potentially costly and disruptive outages, making our digital experiences smoother and more dependable.

What is code?

Code, in the context of software development, is the cornerstone of creating computer software, applications, and websites. It consists of a series of instructions written by programmers in various programming languages like Python, Java, or C++. These instructions tell the computer how to perform specific tasks, ranging from simple functions like displaying a message on the screen to complex operations like processing data or managing user interactions. Code can be thought of as a recipe that the computer follows to execute different activities, with each programming language offering its unique syntax and capabilities to address various problems and requirements.

Understanding code is akin to learning a new language, one that allows for communication with computers to bring digital ideas to life. It serves as the blueprint for everything in the digital world, from the operating system on your smartphone to the apps you use and the websites you visit. Each line of code contributes to the larger structure of a software project, working together to create interactive, functional, and efficient digital experiences. As the foundation of technology, code not only enables the creation of software but also empowers innovation and creativity in the digital age.

What is Code Review?

At its core, code review is a quality assurance practice where developers check each other’s code for mistakes before it becomes part of the main project codebase. This peer evaluation ensures that the code is readable, maintainable, and doesn’t introduce any new errors or vulnerabilities into the system. Think of it as proofreading a book before publication, but instead of looking for grammatical errors, developers are searching for bugs, security loopholes, and performance issues.

The Role of Code Review in Software Development

The primary goal of code review is to maintain the high quality of software projects. By catching errors early, teams can save time and resources that would otherwise be spent fixing problems after the software is released. Additionally, code reviews foster a culture of collaboration and continuous learning among developers, as they get to share best practices and provide constructive feedback.

How Does Code Review Work?

The process begins when a developer, often referred to as the author, completes a piece of code and submits it for review, usually via a version control system like Git to a source code hosting platform like GitHub. Other members of the team, known as reviewers, then examine the code changes, looking for any issues or improvements. These reviews can be conducted in various ways:

  • Line-by-Line Analysis: Reviewers go through the code changes line by line to understand the modifications and assess their impact.
  • Checklists: Some teams use a checklist of common pitfalls and best practices to guide the review process.
  • Automated Tools: Tools like SonarQube or CodeClimate can automatically analyze code for common issues, which helps streamline the review process.

Benefits of Code Review for Non-Technical Stakeholders

While the mechanics of code review might seem deeply technical, the benefits extend across the entire organization:

  • Improved Product Quality: By catching issues early, the final product is more stable and reliable - resulting in a reduction in outages and fewer issues caught by customers.
  • Cost Efficiency: Fixing bugs in the development phase is significantly cheaper than addressing them after release.
  • Faster Development Cycles: Regular reviews help prevent major reworks, keeping projects on schedule.
  • Enhanced Security: Peer review is crucial for identifying and mitigating security vulnerabilities before they can be exploited.

The Human Aspect of Code Reviews

Beyond the technical benefits, code reviews play a vital role in team dynamics and individual growth. They promote a culture of transparency and accountability, where constructive feedback helps everyone improve. For non-technical folks, it’s akin to peer review processes in academic or professional settings, where the collective expertise of the group elevates the quality of work.

Best Practices for Effective Code Review

While the specific practices may vary from one team to another, some universally acknowledged best practices include:

  • Keep Changes Small: Smaller code changes are easier to review thoroughly, making the process more efficient and effective.
  • Clarify Intentions: Authors should provide context for their changes, helping reviewers understand their reasoning.
  • Focus on the Big Picture: Reviewers should prioritize significant issues that impact the overall quality, security, and performance of the code.
  • Foster a Positive Environment: Encourage constructive feedback and maintain a positive tone to support continuous improvement.

The Power of Outside Code Reviewers

Introducing external reviewers to scrutinize your team’s code can further enhance software quality and security, bringing a fresh perspective that internal team members might overlook. External reviewers, unencumbered by the project’s internal biases or assumptions, can identify potential issues, from subtle bugs to critical security vulnerabilities, that internal developers might miss due to familiarity blindness. This process not only mitigates the risk of errors slipping into production but also fosters a culture of learning and improvement within the team. By exposing the team to diverse coding practices and methodologies, external reviews encourage the adoption of best practices and innovative solutions, ultimately elevating the quality and reliability of the software being developed.

To streamline this invaluable process, consider leveraging H1 PullRequest, a pioneering platform that connects your projects with a network of experienced reviewers outside your immediate team. H1 PullRequest harnesses the expertise of top-tier developers across various industries and technology stacks, providing thorough, insightful code reviews that drive quality, performance, and security. This service not only accelerates the development cycle by identifying and resolving issues more efficiently but also enhances team skills through constructive feedback and knowledge sharing. With H1 PullRequest, your software projects gain the advantage of external scrutiny, ensuring they meet the highest standards of code quality, security, and maintainability, while your team continuously evolves through exposure to global best practices.


For those not deeply embedded in the software development landscape, the concept of code review may appear as a highly specialized or technical exercise. Nonetheless, it’s a pivotal element in the creation of reliable and robust technology that underpins our contemporary digital existence. Code review significantly elevates the efficiency, security, and fault tolerance of software, markedly contributing to the reduction of outages and enhancing the overall reliability and performance of digital offerings. Whether you’re a seasoned developer, a project manager overseeing tech initiatives, or simply an individual intrigued by the mechanics of technology, grasping the fundamentals of code review sheds light on the collaborative endeavor that propels software development forward.

Code review transcends mere examination of code syntax; it fosters a culture of excellence, teamwork, and ongoing enhancement that benefits not just the development team but the organization as a whole. This meticulous process paves the way for crafting software that doesn’t just meet but surpasses user expectations and stakeholder standards, thereby laying the groundwork for continuous technological advancement and success. In essence, adopting rigorous code review practices is key to minimizing potential disruptions, ensuring that digital services remain uninterrupted and dependable for users around the globe.

About PullRequest

HackerOne PullRequest is a platform for code review, built for teams of all sizes. We have a network of expert engineers enhanced by AI, to help you ship secure code, faster.

Learn more about PullRequest

Michael Renken headshot
by Michael Renken

March 19, 2024